Land Rover accuses BYD of plagiarism, but the court rules otherwise, giving them 24 hours to destroy the documents or face fines of 50,000 euros per hour.

12/11/2026 13:00
Updated to
12/11/2026 13:00
Jaguar Land Rover has just faced a significant legal setback in its dispute with BYD. A court in The Hague, Netherlands, has ordered the historic British manufacturer to destroy the documents obtained during a search of the Chinese company’s European offices. The ruling sets a 24-hour deadline to carry out the destruction orders and imposes fines of 50,000 euros for each hour of delay, up to a maximum of 500,000 euros.
The origin of the conflict lies with the BYD Ti 7, an SUV sold in China under the Fang Cheng Bao brand that, according to Jaguar Land Rover, bears significant similarities to the Land Rover Defender. The British company suspects that BYD may have used elements from this off-road vehicle to develop its own model, which is why it filed legal actions and requested the seizure of internal documents. However, the Dutch judiciary believes that the documents obtained are not necessary to support these accusations.

A fine of 50,000 euros per hour with a maximum of 500,000 euros
The ruling was issued on November 11 by the District Court of The Hague. Judge H. F. R. van Heemstra overturned the seizure of documents carried out in August at BYD’s offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp, both in the Netherlands. The search was authorized without giving the Chinese manufacturer the opportunity to present its arguments first, as reported by CarNewsChina.
The files were placed under the custody of an independent third party appointed by the court, so they were never handed over directly to Jaguar Land Rover. BYD later appealed the decision, arguing it contained confidential research and development information unrelated to the alleged plagiarism.
Jaguar Land Rover now has 24 hours from the formal notification to order the destruction of the documents and must provide independent confirmation within 24 hours after their destruction. If it fails to meet this first deadline, it will face a penalty of 50,000 euros per hour, capped at 500,000 euros. Additionally, the court imposes another fine of 500,000 euros for each violation of the ban on continuing to enforce the original seizure order.

BYD avoids another 500,000 euro claim but must pay 25,376 euros
The judgment also rejects an economic claim filed by Jaguar Land Rover against BYD. The British manufacturer had requested 500,000 euros in penalties, arguing that its competitor had failed to properly comply with the conditions of the initial intervention. However, the court temporarily concluded that the Chinese company had indeed fulfilled its obligations. Despite this favorable ruling for BYD, the Chinese manufacturer must cover 25,376.57 euros in court costs, as stated in the judgment. The decision is immediately enforceable, even if either party decides to appeal it.
However, it should be noted that the court has not determined whether the BYD Ti 7 actually copies the Land Rover Defender. It has only concluded that Jaguar Land Rover does not need the seized documents to support its claims or to calculate potential financial losses, as the Chinese model has not yet been marketed in the European Union. Proceedings related to the alleged infringement of design rights and intellectual property remain open.
The legal dispute coincides with the arrival of the BYD Ti 7 in the British market. The Chinese manufacturer has announced a 7-seater plug-in hybrid version named Excellence AWD, with first deliveries expected in January 2027.